http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/325/7357/221/b

BMJ 2002;325:221 ( 27 July )

Letters: Adults still account for many deaths from chickenpox

EDITOR---It was good to learn from Brisson et al's letter that the trend of an increasing number of deaths from chickenpox has reversed in the three years since colleagues and I completed our survey. 1 2 However, Brisson et al disagree with our claim that deaths in adults are rising and state that this is misleading.1

Our conclusion that adult deaths had risen was based on statistics covering a period of 31 years (1967-97). Among certified deaths from chickenpox adults accounted for 48% in 1967-77 (88 deaths in 11 years), 64% in 1978-85 (120 deaths in eight years),3 and 81% in 1986-97 (269 deaths in 12 years).

The contention that our data are misleading on the basis of three further years of data compared with our span of 31 years clearly needs to be placed in context. Moreover, there is a precedent for periods of lower mortality, as discussed below for the period 1989-91. The main body of our paper stated that deaths from chickenpox in adults have increased in number and proportion. We inadvertently used the present tense in the abstract and cannot claim to see into the future.

We looked at deaths noted by the Office for National Statistics for the 13 years 1985-97 (table). This table, which was not published in our paper for reasons of space, shows that, except in two years, the annual number of deaths was fairly consistent. The exceptions were 1989 and 1996, when the case fatality rates based on consultation rates from the Royal College of General Practitioners were also exceptional. We have no explanation for this.


                              
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 

Numbers of certified deaths from chickenpox and estimated case fatality rates in England and Wales, 1985-97 

 

The total number of deaths in 1986-8, 1989-91, 1992-4, and 1995-7 were 26, 22, 27, and 27 respectively. This does not show that, as Brisson et al state, "The number of deaths from chickenpox and case fatality rates were significantly higher in 1995-7 [the period of our study] than at any other period." The overall case fatality rates in the table do not show this either.

The main messages of our paper are that mortality from chickenpox is not negligible; adults account for a high proportion of deaths; and the number and proportion of adult deaths increased substantially between 1967 and 1997.

Norman Noah, professor of public health
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WCIE 7HT norman.noah@lshtm.ac.uk

1. Brisson M, Edmunds WJ, Gay NJ, Miller E. Deaths from chickenpox in adults are decreasing. BMJ 2002; 324: 609[Full Text]. (9 March.)
2. Rawson H, Crampin A, Noah N. Deaths from chickenpox in England and Wales 1995-7: analysis of routine mortality data. BMJ 2001; 323: 1091-1093[Abstract/Full Text].
3. Joseph CA, Noah N. Epidemiology of chickenpox in England and Wales, 1967-85. BMJ 1988; 296: 673-676[Medline].

BMJ 2002